Sep 5, 2013
Review: The Not Even Once Club
The Not Even Once Club by Wendy Watson Nelson
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
I loved the illustrator's work in this book but was pretty torn about the message that a child could not even once make a mistake. I agree with the idea to encourage a child to not even once break a commandment, but what if they do? This book almost makes it seem that they will be doomed.
I made the mistake of reading it WITH my 8 year old before I read it myself & my son was stunned & scared that he had broken a Christian belief because he has drank TEA already. That was just a little crazy to have tea & coffee on the list of things to not do NOT EVEN ONCE. I have never seen a commandment that said not to drink tea! I was shocked and angry that my son was made feel a sinner for drinking TEA.
I understand this could have been a great book, but it a little to hell fire & damnation for a child in my opinion. Jesus forgives & children should try to never break the commandments but they will not go straight to hell for drinking a glass of tea. This book was so beautifully illustrated that I really hate that it seemed overly judgmental for a child to be reading.
I was provided a complementary copy of this book for an honest review / opinion.
View all my reviews
**** Stitched #1 The First Day of the Rest of Her Life by Mariah McCourt, Aaron Alexovich The bright, colorful book cover dre...
Happy Easter! We want to help you celebrate by giving you the chance to win a free print copy of the novel Belle Grove by Katherine Wi...
Root Beer Candy and Other Miracles by Shari Green My rating: 4 of 5 stars Review by Aunt Meanie This bo...
On Tour with Prism Book Tours . This is Not a Werewolf Story by Sandra Evans Middle Grade Fantasy Hardcover & ebook, 352 pages July ...